Should the Federal Government Tax Lottery Winnings in Canada?

As it stands today, the federal government inhelp things like non-profit companies, charities,
Canada does not tax lottery winnings. But theprovincial hospitals, sports, and cultural activities,
government is constantly looking for new revenuethe very types of things that taxes would help
and new taxes are always a possibility. Shouldtoo.
they consider a lottery tax?On the other hand, people that want the
Many countries around the world tax lottery wins,government to tax lotteries might say things like
including the United States, Canada's closestif somebody wins a big lottery jackpot, he would
neighbor. In the U.S., not only does the federalbe wealthier than he ever dreamed possible, even
government tax lottery winnings, but so do manyif his winnings were taxed. For example, say
of the State governments. In fact, just recently,someone wins $20 million and it was taxed at,
New Hampshire introduced a new 90% tax; that'ssay, 30%. That would mean that, instead of $20
in addition to the $30% levied by the federalmillion, he would receive an after-tax amount of
government.$14 million. He'd probably be just as happy with
The case could be made that the Canadian$14 million as he would with $20 million.
government should not tax lottery winningsThere are good arguments for and against a
because lottery profits already benefit thelottery tax in Canada. But, in the end, it's really
community. That would be like double-taxation.the governments decision whether or not they
For example, lottery proceeds from OLG (Ontariowould want to implement such a tax.
Lottery and Gaming Corporation), directly goes to